Hands-on with a pre-release Windows Mobile 6.5 Professional ROM from XDA Developers
The success of the iPhone has focused smartphone developers’ attention upon touch. The Blackberry Storm, Palm Pre, T-Mobile G1 (Googlephone) and HTC Touch HD all looked to compete with the iPhone with large screens and touch interfaces.
Under the hood of the Touch HD was Windows Mobile with HTC’s TouchFlo finger-friendly overlay. Like historical versions of the Palm and Blackberry OSes, Windows Mobile has generally been aimed at stylus+button input which has made it fast for savvy users. However in an iPhone age greater accessibility is required and Windows Mobile 6.5 aims to achieve this.
We’ll be looking at a pre-release XDA Developers build of WinMo 6.5 Professional on an HTC Touch Pro (Raphael model), so the actual features I describe may be different to the ones available in the full future release. We will also concentrate on the significant changes from WinMo 6.1, as much of 6.5 is closely related to 6.1.
Honeycomb application launcher
Many early photos of WinMo 6.5 showed the now-famous honeycomb lattice application launcher, designed to create more space between icons and make the easier to target with a finger. In the version I’m trying the lattice borders are not present but the formation is there. The icons are far easier to target than in 6.1, I haven’t missed any yet.
Swiping and scrolling
The scrolling action to reveal further pages of applications has been hugely improved. Finger swipes now scroll the screen with ease, locking at each page if the swipe is gentle or scrolling through multiple pages if stronger. The top/bottom bouncing effect has been borrowed from the iPhone and it works well.
This also extends within applications, such as Windows Live where mailbox scolling and mail selection has been made far more finger friendly. Track forward/back changes in Windows Media player are also a side-swipe away.
Pre-6.5 applications currently have variable scolling implementations however. AvantGo, for example, still scrolls as well as it did before but the new bouncing effect is not present.
Battery life
I’ve noticed a colossal improvement in battery life on the Touch Pro compared to it’s original AT&T 6.1 build. The Touch Pro will now easily last a full day with regular periods of data usage.
It’s difficult to know what has caused this uptick, possibly it’s due to more efficient CPU or memory calls or perhaps the lack of HTC’s graphics intensive TouchFlo overlay means the system is being taxed less. It’s certainly a welcome change and makes the Touch Pro a usable phone for my usage pattern. YMMV.
3G stability improvements
Whilst 6.1 is a pretty stable OS, the Touch Pro previously had sporadic 3G connection issues which required a reboot. These issues have vanished on this 6.5 version, and data seems to download significantly faster. Note that I did not change the radio firmware when I installed 6.5.
So far 6.5 has not crashed on me once, but I have rebooted twice over the last two weeks to refresh the system. Rebooting is definitely faster than with 6.1, but I put that primarily down to not having to launch TouchFlo following the OS boot.
Finger-friendly menus
All of the 6.5 menus have grown to be more finger-friendly. It’s now easy to hit the target with confidence. Even though 6.1 on the Touch Pro had some big menus in places, my hit rate in 6.5 has greatly improved and there might be better coding under the hood making this happen.
Everything else
Much of the remaining experience is similar to using 6.1. The apps I’ve tried to download, such as Google Maps and AvantGo have worked perfectly.
Is it a game changer?
Whether you like the underlying Windows Mobile platform is a matter of personal taste. Whilst this version of 6.5 has been great to use on the Touch Pro it continues to be hampered by the relatively small screen of most Windows Mobile devices compared to the iPhone. This means that making Windows Mobile, Blackberry OS or any other small screen device close-in on the iPhone in terms of finger-friendliness will always be a huge task.
The continued breadth of form factors also hampers efforts, although Microsoft is now starting to get more specific on hardware which should help to standardize the platform for developers writing for a more consistent user experience. RIM had a similarly diffcult experience taking the Blackberry OS and porting it to the Storm, which was received with mixed opinions.
So all I need now is a Touch Pro with a full length screen, same keyboard and only 3-4 oz in weight. That’s not the Touch Pro2, but perhaps it could be the Touch Pro3…
Neil Berman
HTC Snap / Dash II Hands-On
I used to have an HTC S620 / Dash as my daily phone and found it to be a near perfect Blackberry-form-factor Windows Mobile smartphone. It was light with a great keyboard and decent screen. The main omissions were a lack of 3G and high resolution camera.
HTC is hoping to fix that in a snap, The Snap to be precise. As a replacement for the S620 / Dash, the Snap is immediately recognizable as a member of the same family with a near identical form factor. Here’s a quick hands-on of the Snap.
Addressing my wish list above, the Snap offers 7.2MB/sec HSDPA compared to the S620’s slow-ish EDGE. WiFi b/g is carried over from the S620, but might not be enabled on all carriers; it was disabled on the Sprint example here.
The Snap also winds the onboard camera optics up to 2MP, which is no great shakes compared to the 5 or 8MP offerings of other smartphones available today. Why is HTC so reluctant to implement leading edge cameras into its cellphones?
The keyboard follows the solid functionality of the S620 with an even better feel. Keys are raised in the center and easy to press. The revised layout placing keys similarly to a computer QWERTY rather than a vertical alignment works well.
A2DP and AVRCP Bluetooth profiles are also implemented, as on the S620, to give stereo bluetooth headsets control of calls and music playback.
On Sprint’s network data downloaded to Internet Explorer
significantly faster than my S620 on AT&T’s EDGE connection. The Snap’s 528MHz processor also made the Windows Mobile 6.1 Standard experience feel snappy compared to the S620’s 200MHz processor, which I admittedly throttle back to 160MHz to save battery power.
So why no Windows Mobile 6.5 on the Snap…? This is certainly disappointing, especially given all the 6.5 online chatter currently. Hopefully a 6.5 upgrade option will be available for the Snap in time. My experience of an early 6.5 Pro touch-enabled build on the HTC Touch Pro has been extremely positive.
Is the Snap worth an upgrade for current S620 / Dash owners? Definitely for high data users, maybe for others. The S620 was already a gem of a device and the Snap offers even more of the same. It just does it, well, a bit snappier.
Neil Berman
AT&T Fuze / HTC Touch Pro P4600 hands-on review
Last year I wrote about the HTC TyTN, which was later superceded by the TyTN II (AT&T Tilt) as the daddy of all productivity smartphones. Since then HTC has moved on with its Touch range which aim to turn up the style, which was a bit lacking in the TyTN series.
Of the three new Touch models (Diamond, Pro and HD) the Pro is the closest successor to the TyTN range with its slide out keyboard. I will make comparisons along the way to the Samsung Epix, which does a similar job in a very different style.
Picking up the Fuze is an altogether different experience to the Tilt it replaced. HTC has taken everything good about the TyTN range and made it sleeker. The all glass look is smart and the back cover has the beautiful angled surface first seen on the Touch Diamond.
One backwards step compared to the Tilt is the reduced number of buttons on the front of the Fuze. Whilst instant access application buttons are present on the keyboard like the Samsung Epix, the Fuze makes you either slide out the keyboard or use screen presses like the iPhone. Whilst this is not a huge problem it does make the Epix feel like a quicker phone to navigate.
The other significant change from the Tilt is that the Fuze loses the tilting screen, which seemed like a fragile but useful feature on its predecessor.
The Fuze feels mightily more petite to hold than the Tilt, but still a tad chunky in its depth to accommodate the keyboard. Overall it looks smaller than the Blackberry Bold or the Samsung Epix but the Fuze’s 6oz weight makes the 4.4oz Epix less bulky in a pocket.
The Fuze has a more useful keyboard than the TyTN series and most other smartphones. There are now five rows of keys, which reduces combination presses to a minimum. The keys also have a positive feel, which aids typing speed.
For those who like to work outdoors, the Fuze’s screen is far brighter than the Tilt’s. I’m writing this outside in full-on New York bright winter sunshine. You don’t get much color contrast, but at least you can see what you’re doing.
The Fuze’s big screen advance is its resolution which, at 640×480, is simply spectacular. The only comparison worth making is to the Blackberry Bold, whose screen is of similar quality.
The TyTN series packed a powerful punch for its time and the Fuze hits even harder. The Fuze has a whopping 0.5GB of ROM for Windows Mobile to play around with. Pair that up with a 528MHz processor and you have a device which flies along. At one point I had 15 applications open simultaneously and the Fuze just kept going. Operating system navigation is very responsive and AT&T’s Cellular Video streams well, as long as you have good 3G coverage.
There is also a MicroSD card slot which can handle cards up to 32GB to satisfy your thirst for videos/music/photos/applications. MicroSD cards are now pretty cheap, I saw an 8GB card recently for $18. However the Fuze loses brownie points for hiding it’s card slot under the back cover, unlike the TyTN which had exposed access on the side of the phone like the Samsung Epix.
The Fuze comes with Opera Mobile as the default browser. This does a good job and offers multiple tabs and good finger control, but still plays second fiddle to Safari on the iPhone. This is partly due to the iPhone’s larger screen and also because Safari renders pages better overall in my opinion.
HTC has enhanced its TouchFlo interface to ‘3D’ status with the inclusion of some nice widgets which make navigation very finger-friendly. The email and music screens look good and scrolling through text messages and photos is great as one item is swept away to make room for the next.
Battery life on the Fuze is only average, with a charge required on a nightly basis following moderate usage. Regular video streaming eats battery time, as does constant surfing although I did find that a full day of battery life is realistic with sensible usage.
The Fuze ships with Windows Mobile 6.1 Professional, which means you get Office Mobile, Windows Media Player and Windows Live. In addition to Messenger the phones also have IM clients for AIM and Yahoo and you can install third party applications to give access to more services. Google Maps, AvantGo and Skype were one-click installs.
Overall the Fuze is a great smartphone. In day to day usage I can’t decide if I prefer the trick TouchFlo 3D interface, sleek looks and amazing screen of the Fuze over the faster front panel key and mouse navigation of the Samsung Epix. There is a popular perception that touch is the way foward, but if reactions to the iPhone have told us anything it’s that people still want keyboards.
If you’re looking for a Windows Mobile smartphone then the Fuze does a great job, however if you prefer buttons to fingers it’s worth checking out the Samsung Epix too.
Neil Berman
Samsung Epix SGH-i907 – Blackjack’s big brother is an Ace
Samsung’s Blackjack II recently topped Consumer Report’s January 2009 smartphone ratings, beating both the iPhone and G1. So this as unsung hero gets its due reward it’s time to check out its new big brother, the Epix.
The Epix shares a family resemblance with the Blackjack and has a traditional keyboard below screen layout. 
The keyboard can be extensively customized to give instant access to your favorite applications, which is great for people who like instant access rather than wading through screens or menus to find applications. Soft keys sit under the large 320×320 haptic and touch sensitive screen and a volume rocker is on the left side. The Epix feels good to hold, slightly heavier than the Blackjack II at 4.4oz, but lighter than the iPhone, G1 and Fuze.
On the media front, the rear houses a decent 2MP camera which also takes videos. Unfortunately there is no flash or light. There is a proprietary charging/headphone port, but the Epix offers stereo bluetooth connectivity so having annoying wires dangling around is not really a concern. If you must stay wired in to satisfy some kind of 20th century nostalgia then there is an adaptor in the box.
The real innovation of the Epix lives in the middle of the front of the phone – there’s an optical trackpad to aid one-handed use…and it’s awesome.
The trackpad is similar to the design on Samsung’s Omnia, but the superior placement on the Epix makes it an amazingly efficient way to navigate. Steer with thumb impulses, click with a press and hold down to display context sensitive menus. Sweet. Precision is so good that the stylus is unlikely to get much use. The trackpad can also be converted to a four way directional pad if desired.
The Epix is a powerhouse compared to the BlackjackII, packing a 624MHz processor, 25MB ROM and 128MB RAM. It also has expansion capability via now-cheap MicroSD cards up to 32GB to satisfy your thirst for home videos/music/photos/applications. The MicroSD slot is on the right hand side of the phone for easy access.
A big contributor to the total weight of the phone is the battery, and being a 3G device with a fast CPU the Epix needs need all the juice it can get. In my mixed tests of light surfing, background IM, stereo bluetooth in transit and a limited amount of calls, the Epix easily managed a full day and two might be possible with bluetooth off. Beyond that a charge will be required.
The Epix ships with Windows Mobile 6.1 Professional, which means you get Office Mobile, Windows Media Player and Windows Live. In addition to Messenger the phone also has IM clients for AIM and Yahoo and you can install third party applications to give access to more services.
Google Maps, AvantGo and Skype were one-click installs as were Opera Mobile and Skyfire to provide options for the aging Internet Explorer. The Epix is easily powerful enough to run several applications simultaneously. 
I had no difficulty sync’ing 1,500 AvantGo pages whilst walking down the street streaming music over bluetooth with IM and email active in the background.
The Epix can be used to access AT&T’s Cellular Video service. So if you have the right plan or are prepared to pay then you get access to news, sports and entertainment from the likes of CNN, ESPN and Comedy Central. The quality is pretty good as long as you are in an area with good 3G coverage.
The Epix has WiFi b/g is onboard, which is useful for Skype but for most other applications AT&T’s 3G network proved almost as fast. The Epix can be tethered for use as a modem if you have the appropriate data plan. There’s also GPS onboard.
What didn’t I like about the Epix? Well although the screen is big it pales in comparison to the resolution of the HTC Touch Pro’s, but then so do most other cellphone screens at the moment. Squeezing VGA (and beyond) resolution into cellphone screens is definitely the way forward.
The 2MP camera takes good shots and videos were also good enough for occasional usage, but 3-5MP is quickly becoming the norm. I don’t see any need for cellphones to replicate the compact camera megapixel wars (although this is inevitable) but Samsung should roll out the higher quality cameras now present in some of its other top end phones.
Whilst we are on the wish list, although 3G cellphones need big batteries it would still be nice to get back to the Blackjack II’s weight.
In summary the Epix is a great smartphone whose powers of endearment outweigh its ordinary appearance. It’s an Ace follow-up to the Blackjack II.
Neil Berman
Sony promises to increase prices, meanwhile Dell offers PS3 for $319.99
Now here’s a good holiday deal. If you’ve been waiting for Sony to drop the price of the PS3 you may need to wait a little longer. But…if you head on over to Dell’s US website pretty sharpish you can snag one for 20% off for a limited time. Not sure if that will help Sony catch the monthly sales of 2 MILLION Wiis shipped in November alone, 
but it might help prolong the PS3’s agony a little longer…especially as how it was crushed 2 to 1 by the XBox 360 and 5 to 1 by the Wii last month. NPD’s reported sales figures for Nov were Wii: 2,040k units, Xbox 360: 836k units, PS3: 378k units.
Interestingly the ratio of Xbox 360 sales to PS3 in October was 1.87 to 1, whilst in November the 360 pulled ahead to 2.21 to 1, probably due to the price cut. Microsoft clearly doesn’t need to do much to ward off the PS3 anymore, rather it seems to have it’s eyes on the Wii’s spot instead…although I can’t see it happening in this console generation. It’s sure turned out different to the way we all thought back in 2005 though, the Playstation franchise needs something big now and these days Sony is in big trouble.
Back on the home front, I’ve been nurturing an ever-growing addiction to Halo 3 on the XBox 360. I have 
been joining the faithful army of online Spartans and when I say army, think mass hordes…there are typically 250-300,000 Halo 3 gamers online each evening, US time.
Helping to make all this happen for me is a new Trendnet router. 
Replacing a Trendnet 108mbps b/g, this 300mbps b/g/n speed demon has gigabit ethernet and flies along with rock-like stability. Installation was a breeze, but pretty please Trendnet next time add a MAC address import feature; typing in all those addresses gets tiring!
I’ve also been giving the new HTC Touch Pro (at&t Fuze, the one the half gig ROM and 288mb RAM) and Samsung i907 (at&t Epix, the one with the optical mouse) a good workout recently…reviews to follow shortly. Suffice to say they’re not too shabby.
Neil Berman
HTC Excalibur S620 / T-Mobile Dash Review
Brushed aluminum finish looks smart
HTC comes up with some great names for its cellphones. Diamond, Kaiser and Wizard have all figured in their recent line-up. The Excalibur looks a bit different from King Arthur’s mythical sword, but can it slay the competition in the same way?
Taking the smartphone out of the box it’s immediately obvious that this is one device which looks way better in real life than on the web. The Excalibur screams quality with a brushed aluminum and soft-feel black finish encasing a flush fitting screen. It’s light too at 130 grams. The battery cover hides the SIM and Micro SD card slots. Other specs include a 200MHz processor, WiFi b/g, EDGE (no HSPA unfortunately), Windows Mobile and of course the music loving stereo bluetooth.
Keypad has good tactile feedback
The Excalibur’s Blackberry/Palm style keyboard has tightly packed raised keys which illuminate blue when the phone’s backlight is on. The keys on these devices are always a matter of taste, personally I find the Excalibur’s okay with plenty of tactile feedback but inferior to HTC’s own TyTN and Kaiser (AT&T Tilt) with their wider and larger keys. The Excalibur could also do with a couple more assignable keys. There are ones for email, internet and the camera but I’d also like ones to assign to Windows Media Player, the connections manager and the task manager for easy application switching.
Which leads me to the JOGGR slidy-thing on the right side of the screen is a curious surface, which offers up/down controls as well as two assignable buttons. Some carriers choose to disable this control surface, which to be honest I can understand. It’s a great idea but too easy to brush it accidentally which can be annoying. Once I got the hang of the JOGGR it did become useful, but might be too fiddly to win fans during a five minute in-store test drive. I would have preferred a hardware wheel and buttons.
Powering up the Excalibur illuminates the stunning 2.4 inch screen, which is a joy to use indoors and out.
2.4 inch screen is bright and sharp
Whilst not readable in direct sunlight, it is possible to use this phone outdoors on a bright day. The flush fitting screen gives a paper flat image, but is also very exposed if the cellphone in jiggling about in a pocket next to some keys. There was a protective belt holster in my box, which is a useful screen preserving accessory.
The version I’m using has Ricky Wyatt’s Windows Mobile 6 ROM with a few added extras taking it to 6.1 spec, such as the newer Windows Live client which does a great job of pushing mails to the device for certain web-based non-POP3 email clients. Another sweet tool on the ROM is an over/underclocking tool for the the 200MHz processor, which allows manually forced power saving and power enhancement. This is a great addition as most usage only needs 150MHz or so, which helps to extend battery life nicely. Running the Excalibur at this speed I was able to listen to music over stereo bluetooth and read the newspapers on AvantGo.
Other tasty morsels in this ROM include Opera Mini which works great on the Excalibur and Resco Explorer which is a good replacement for File Explorer. I also added Google Maps, which renders extremely quickly on the Excalibur compared to my TyTN and scarily pinpointed my location to within one city block.
Excalibur is size zero thin
The sound performance of the Excalibur is up to HTC’s usual high standards overall. Sound quality from the earpiece and microphone both seem fine, although the speaker was a bit tinny and unlikely to break any cellphone records for bass response. The stereo bluetooth paired to my Logitech Freepulse easily and sound quality was exceptionally clear, so you can give those wired adphones back to the twentieth century where they belong. The USB charging port doubles up as a headphone/hands-free port. Whilst there are adaptors available to let you use wired 3.5mm phones, you’ll probably prefer to stick with the stereo bluetooth to avoid dangling wires…after all with a micro sd slot to play with, the Excalibur could store your entire music collection so you might as well look the business while you’re listening.
Battery life was good, and as always was influenced by the amount of wireless connectivity and data usage. Forcing the screen to dim quickly after periods of inactivity also helped. With mixed usage including some WiFi and EDGE data action, voice calls and listening to music over stereo bluetooth I got just over one day before the Excalibur asked to be returned to the lake for some juice.
Can the Excalibur slay the competition? It’s certainly a strong Windows Mobile cellphone, nay very strong when paired with some useful added software. At 130 grams it competes directly with RIM’s Blackberry Curve, which ends in a tie for me with RIM’s solid messaging experience battling the huge Windows Mobile application development community. If you do go for the Excalibur though, it’s a worthy sword to have in the armory.
Neil Berman
Ricky Wyatt’s Excalibur ROM is available at XDA Developers. I do not recommend flashing a ROM onto your cellphone. Flashing a ROM onto your cellphone is done entirely at your own risk, can brick your phone, will most likely invalidate your warranty and might lead to a total freak-out if it goes horribly wrong!!
Thanks to Joan & Alan for this one.
Gallery:
-
- Brushed aluminum finish looks smart
-
- Keypad has good tactile feedback
-
- 2.4 inch screen is bright and sharp
-
- Back plate covers battery, SIM and micro SD slot
-
- 1.3MP camera is alright, but nothing special
-
- USB charging connector doubles as handsfree/headphone output
-
- Excalibur is size zero thin
-
- Micro SD slot gives huge storage potential
-
- Windows Mobile panels include media player
iPhone Exchange Policy
For months iPhone has been the coolest device on the street. Everyone wants one, but so far they have scared corporate IT managers who see them as a security hole in the network. But those IT managers have faced a growing problem over recent times: it’s called user pressure.
That’s because many iPhone owners are well-heeled business types who want to swap out their work Blackberry. However in most enterprises it’s difficult to exchange a Blackberry for a smartphone which doesn’t support Exchange.
Apple’s changed that now and kudos to them for listening to their customers. iPhone now supports push email, calendar and contacts from an Exhange Server via a licensed Microsoft ActiveSync client. iPhone’s user experience remains intact because email is handled by the cellphone’s regular email interface. Many of the industry’s security concerns have been addressed and there’s now a remote wipe facility.
Apple has also opened up the iPhone SDK (Software Development Kit) so third parties can write real applications for it. This means we could see virtual remote access clients from the likes of Citrix, VMWare and other companies to allow users to go straight into their office network. Who knows, maybe Microsoft will even release a version of Office Mobile for iPhone. The operating system is an optimized OS X with Touch enhancements to the Cocoa interface, so ports of regular Mac software could be coming soon.
iPhone is now a real contender in the corporate email battle and it could be the first Apple product to do well in mainstream US companies. Why? Not because it’s good to type on or has an established history (Blackberry and Windows Mobile win easily). No, it’s simply because users will want it. They will demand it, as they have been doing so far…the difference now is that IT departments can actually deliver a solution. Like Windows Mobile, that solution comes right out of the Exchange Server rather than routing through an additional Blackberry message server, so the service delivery has less infrastructure points of failure.
Of course just because the functionality exists doesn’t mean that companies will buy it. But if I was the head of RIM marketing I would be pretty scared right now. Apple clearly means business for the first time, and the users will be on their side. If they can get the pricing right then the competition is in for some tough years ahead.
Now where’s that iPhone drawing I was doing with the slide out keyboard…?
Click here to see if iPhone can survive a Maine Coon mauling.
Neil Berman
www.neilberman.com
Problem: iPhone and Lotus Notes have low corporate market share. Solution? Ask for an Exchange.
For those who’ve never heard of it Notes is a clunky communications client, which prior to the most recent release 8.0 sent out-of-office messages at 2am by default instead of notifying the sender immediately.
Doesn’t sound like an ideal launch pad for an iPhone corporate takeover.
Microsoft recently released Office 2008 for Mac, so there is a working relationship there. Would an iPhone Exchange client be too much competition for Windows Mobile devices? Blackberries and Exchange have been happy partners for ages, so Microsoft does not seem to have a desire to restrict access to WM devices only. Perhaps IBM just got earlier access to the iPhone SDK.
One thing’s for sure, the corporate Outlook for iPhone looks bleak without an Exchange of ideas with Microsoft.
Neil Berman
www.neilberman.com
theONbutton
Turning the world on, one gadget at a time.
